Search the site by keyword

Estimating quality-adjusted productivity in tertiary education

Authors

Dr Patrick Nolan

Norman Gemmell

Grant Scobie
Independent researcher

Date published

1 November 2017

Download [1.5 MB PDF]

This paper constructs quality adjusted productivity indices for the tertiary education sector. It proposes a number of methods for making quality adjustments to measures of labour and multifactor productivity and applies those to the public tertiary sector in New Zealand over 2000-15.

Quality-adjusted productivity measures for teaching across the tertiary sector as a whole are produced as well as measures of research productivity for universities. Our evidence suggests that quality adjustment, to both inputs and outputs, can make substantial differences to conclusions about productivity trends over 2000-15.

In the case of tertiary teaching productivity, adjusting student numbers for the completion of qualifications suggests positive, rather than zero, productivity growth in the sector, largely driven by an expansion in nonuniversity providers. In the case of research productivity (universities only) weighting research output for citations amplifies measures of productivity growth following the introduction of the Performance Based Research Funding (PBRF) regime. Especially important, but rarely discussed, components of those adjustment are (i) methods of deflating financial variables within some tertiary productivity measures; and (ii) how universities allocate resources between teaching and research.

Share

Research

Understanding New Zealand’s productivity performance

Our research aims to understand New Zealand's productivity performance and the role of policy in lifting productivity. 

Explore our publications below, hear us present at an event or contact us with your productivity questions.

A photo by Richard Clyborne of Music Strive

Productivity growth

The goal of our research is to facilitate a move from an economy that grows by using more “inputs” (such as labour or natural resources), to one where productivity plays a greater role in driving economic growth – essentially, working smarter, with greater financial and knowledge capital employed per worker.

Our research explores a wide range of productivity issues: employment, firm dynamics, technology diffusion, innovation, regional development, spatial and public-sector productivity.


Working together

The commissioning of research and the practice of collaboration with others is important to us. It enables us to access subject/sector specialists and benefit from the cross-promotion of ideas and insights. You will find research from the Commission, as well as research we commissioned, below.


Strengthening learning

Our Economics & Research team is independently evaluated every two years to understand how to improve and enhance our impact. See the latest evaluation report and 2020 survey results here.


Publications

Filter publications by topic.

Load more publications